- Library
- Research Guides
- RD 115 Evans
- Activities
RD 115 Evans: Activities
Responsible practice with generative AI
it is imperative to understand that text or images are not context free (even AI-generated ones), especially within the frame of information literacy, that is: how sources are created; how sources are valued; how research works.
Generative AI results have been derived from sources, online conversations, and predictive text training.
It is one thing (and very convenient) to ask about something you can easily judge for credibility and usefulness on your own (for example, the top ten women's basketball teams; suggestions for a list of the most important writers on a topic; the best kind of washing machines and price comparisons for the local area).
It will be risky to rely on AI generated results for something you don't know about. And much more risky to use AI to complete an assignment for you, where you short-circuit your own learning process.
Generative AI tools provide essentially summaries of information, usually without providing context, or acknowledgement of where the information came from.
The activities on this page can help you learn about the possible consequences of using generative artificial intelligence tools, to learn how they work.
Use a claim
Ask for something on a claim that you suspect may not tell the entire story, such as:
- Books harmful to children at the Library of Congress
What might be missing from the AI text?
Next, search for sources from groups you know would be interested or involved with different aspects of the claim
-
American Library Association: Banned BooksThe Library of Congress does own a copy of a book some deem to be harmful to children.
Query the situation -- What is missing from the story? One part is that the Library of Congress is not a lending library the collections are for members of Congress-- not children
Find local stories
Ask about an issue with a local context, and then compare it to a result from a local newspaper or broadcast news outlet.
Such as: portland oregon parking tickets worst offenders
-
Williamette WeekUse the site search.
Keep the search simple, like: parking tickets. Then browse the results, see what the local or recent controversies are.
PCC Library guide
Check if the generative AI tool will create hallucinations
Ask for text on the pros and cons for a topic you know a lot about.
Next step: Ask for five sources to support the claims
Check:
- Do the links work?
- What types of sites are you linking to?
- Are the sites incorrect in some way, or, wholly hallucinated?
Third step: Ask for a summary of text from a falsified URL. If there are links given, what do they look like?
-
ChatGPT couldn’t access the internet, even though it really looked like it couldArticle.
Reading (using) URLs may be improving, but can still be problematic for generative AI
AI Impact on Research and Information Literacy
Some AI tools are now connecting to Google search, but identifying sources from the realm of the information ecosystem remains problematic. Finding sources such as these can be difficult with AI requests:
- research studies
- primary sources
- broadcast news outlets
- government documents
- articles that have been edited and published by recognized or academic publishers
AI doesn't fact-check or triangulate, but relies instead on the frequency of terms.
It will find answers for what you ask, whether the question is based in reality or not. If you ask for experts, it may reflect bias from what it LLM has been trained with. It would be better to ask for what the conversations by experts that are that are currently taking place around a topic and then finding and evaluating what they have published.